Dateline: Secrets Uncovered season 14 episode 19- A detailed case overview

The terrible case of five-year-old Timothy Wiltsey, who went missing from a Sayreville, New Jersey carnival on May 25, 1991, is investigated in Dateline: Secrets Uncovered season 14 episode 19. The show delves into the enigmatic events around Timothy's vanishing and the yearslong inquiry that followed.

Michelle Lodzinski, Timothy's mother, said he was missing from the carnival. However, her varying accounts and odd actions quickly made her a suspect. Years passed before Timothy's remains were found in April 1992 in a dank location close to an office park where Lodzinski had previously worked.

The case remained unsolved from then on. However, Lodzinski's arrest and charge of her son's murder in 2014 caused the investigation to take a sharp turn.

In this installment of Dateline: Secrets Uncovered, the convoluted case, the ensuing trial, and the contentious Supreme Court decision that in 2021 overturned Lodzinski's sentence are discussed.

Background of Dateline: Secrets Uncovered

Dateline: Secrets Uncovered is a true crime show offering a thorough analysis of difficult criminal trials. The program seeks to bring to light undetected aspects of several crimes and inquiries via long-form narrative stories.

By engaging viewers via interviews, professional analysis, and behind the scenes looks into the road to justice, each episode of Dateline: Secrets Uncovered revisits older and current court cases. Dateline: Secrets Uncovered is known for its thorough narrative style that highlights the difficulties and advancements of criminal investigations.

About the Crime

According to reports, four South Amboy, New Jersey five-year-old Timothy Wiltsey went missing at an event in Sayreville not far from May 25, 1991. Michelle Lodzinski, his mother, said Timothy vanished when she was getting a soda.

Although investigators combed the carnival premises and neighboring locations, there was no sign of Timothy. His vanishing set off a strong and immediate investigation.

Investigation

According to reports, Timothy's disappearance inquiry was complex and long. At first, police interviewed visitors and carnival workers, but they found no major leads. Lodzinski's version of the events changed several times, therefore the detectives became skeptical.

She said she had left Timothy with a woman called Ellen and two guys in June 1991, but they had disappeared by the time she came back. According to reports, she claimed later that one of the guys had held Timothy at knifepoint.

Timothy's skeletal remains were found in a swampy area close to the Raritan Center industrial park in Edison, New Jersey, in April 1992, which greatly changed the case. The spot was near an office park where Lodzinski had worked previously. Investigators found a blanket and other stuff along with the remains that would eventually help solve the case.

Resolution

According to reports, though Timothy was found, the case remained open for years. Michelle Lodzinski was arrested in Florida and charged with her son's murder on August 6, 2014, what would have been Timothy's 29th birthday.

The arrest followed years of doubt over Lodzinski's connection to her son's vanishing, together with a grand jury indictment. Starting in 2016, the trial kicked off with attorneys introducing circumstantial evidence, including the blanket found with Timothy's body witnesses said came from the Lodzinski residence. The jury convicted Lodzinski of murder after hearing evidence from 68 witnesses.

Aftermath

According to NBC New York, Lodzinski was given a 30-year jail sentence without parole after she was found guilty. But in December 2021, when the New Jersey Supreme Court set aside Lodzinski's sentence, the case changed once more.

The court decided that 43 of the evidence offered at trial was inadequate to show beyond a reasonable doubt that Lodzinski had intentionally or knowingly caused Timothy's death.

Timothy Wiltsey's case is still among New Jersey's most infamous and contentious criminal cases. Michelle Lodzinski's conviction being overturned has sparked fresh discussions on the power of circumstantial evidence in criminal trials and the difficulties of trying cold cases.

Dateline: Secrets Uncovered airs on March 19, on Oxygen.

​